It can - at least in theory - be a good idea to have universal requirements for something that is useful in and of itself. Everyone has to do a stint in the army, because we need soldiers and that’s where we get them, or maybe because we believe that military service builds character or something. Everyone has to go to kindergarten, because kindergarten teaches things that we’re confident every student can learn and should learn and will be able to learn. The prize for teaching kids to read is “those kids can read,” and you can just stop there, you don’t need any kind of elaborate scaffolding of justification.
I am increasingly convinced that any universal requirement for something that isn’t useful in and of itself, for something that might or might not be valuable based on How the Facts Turn Out, will always prove to be a terrible idea.
Or, in briefer terms: if you’re going to base your policy decision on a claim that “Everyone Can X!,” you have to really really really mean it.
Alley homes in DC.
